January 28, 2008

Fifths Rule

By Greg McMillan

I tend to be descriptive instead of proscriptive in my discussion of process control and improvement. This may be due to my interest in the scientific method and concepts rather than details that may only be good for specific sets of conditions. However, there are certain rules of thumb based on solid principles that serve as guidance for good practices. It is interesting how the factor 1/5 turns up over and over again. So here is a list where "fifths" rule for best performance. For my drinking buddies, this is not about best bottles.

(1) loop dead time < 1/5 x (process time constant + load time constant)*
(2) measurement filter time < 1/5 x (process time constant + load time constant)*
(3) module execution time < 1/5 x (loop dead time)
(4) module execution time < 1/5 x (process time constant)
(5) measurement scan time < 1/5 x (module execution time)
(6) standard deviation < 1/5 x (allowable control error)
(7) noise in controller output < 1/5 x (required change in controller output)
(8) stick-slip of valve < 1/5 x (required changed in controller output)
(9) half dead band of valve < 1/5 x (required changed in controller output)
(10) secondary loop time constant < 1/5 x (primary loop time constant)
(11) secondary loop dead time < 1/5 x (primary loop dead time)
(12) controller gain < 1/5 x (ultimate gain)
(13) controller rate setting < 1/5 x (process time constant)
(14) historian update time < 1/5 x (oscillation period)

* - your main hope for dead time processes is to slow down the load disturbance.

My final recommendation is the 3-D U2 concert film. I have been in front row seats for BB King, BTO, and Joan Jett but this was even better for seeing and feeling how musicians get into their music. Bono and Edge were 7 feet tall playing right above you. The positive energy from the lyrics and instrumentation was incredible.



14 Comments

Hello, cheers for a wonderful article, a truly great opening for the 2010, keep up the great work, Angela.

Hi, cheers for this great article, a really great start to the new year, keep up the fantastic work, Rachel.

Hi, thank you for the excellent blog, a truly great beginning for the 2010, keep up the great work, Cheryl.

Hello there, thanks for this great article, a truly great beginning for the 2010, keep up the wonderful work, Brenda.

Hi there, cheers for the great article, a really great beginning to the new year, keep up the excellent work, Anne.

Nice one, there is actually some worthwhile facts on this post some of my friends may find this worthwhile, I must send a link, thanks.

I have been looking looking around for this kind of information. Will you post some more in future? I will be grateful if you will.

Greetings, Ilike your blog very much. It has relatedinfo in it. I came here from search engine cuil while was searching for music info. Keep working on blog I d place bookmark, thanks.

Hello admin, I found your beautiful blog from google and had scan throughly a few of your other posts and I must say they are very high quality, please keeping up the great work!!!! Greets,

Hello, super post, I really enjoyed reading this. the article gave me the push to attempt my own article, please check my post by clicking my name at the top of this article, thanks

, great post, I really enjoyed reading it. This blog gave me the momentum to try my own post, please check my post by clicking my name at the top of this article, cheers

, fantastic blog, I thouroughly enjoyed reading this. the blog gave me the momentum to attempt my own post, please see my blog by clicking my name at the top of this post, thanks

Hello there, superb post, I thouroughly enjoyed reading it. the article gave me the momentum to try my own article, please see my post by clicking my name at the top of this post, thank you

Hi, excellent article, I really enjoyed reading it. the blog gave me the kick to try my own blog, please check out my article by clicking my name at the top of this post, thank you


Leave a comment


Subscribe

Archives

The opinions expressed here are the personal opinions of Greg McMillan and Terry Blevins. Content published here is not read or approved by Emerson before it is posted and does not necessarily represent the views and opinions of Emerson. © 2006-2010 Greg McMillan and Terry Blevins. All rights reserved.